Preston Manning's plea to stop the insenaty
In a bold, open letter to all senators, former Reform/Canadian Alliance leader Preston Manning afronted them with the growing mood amongst democratic Canadians that the problem with not moving forward on senate reform is caused by the current senators themselves who've done nothing on it. This, despite the relatively recent Conservative majority and a bulk of whom were appointed by recommendation of Prime Minister Harper on the basis that they would reform it.
With a recent Nanos poll indicating almost half of Canadians want the Senate reformed and just under that amount want it abolished, with few taking the status quo, it's the abolish side that is growing, probably because reforming it is seemingly less and less likely.
On this blog, I've gone on and on for years regarding politicians who say we reform the senate but offer no ideas, solutions or say it's difficult to do so there's no point. This behaviour I've coined "insenaty". Manning has basically painted the entire red chamber in asylum-white while senators sit back and strap themselves in straight-jackets whining that reform is a fruitless exercise. Sigh.
I've offered my ideas over and over. I prefer reforming it to abolishing it. But even I've become frustrated, as I see little action despite my acknowledgement of Stephen Harper's term-limit proposal and preference for appointing elected senators (albeit only from Alberta thus far), he's the most reformist of all PMs in our history.
And as my frustration grows with my age, I lean toward perhaps abolishing it to then start from scratch may be the preferred route to rid the upper chamber of the "Ottawashed" and replace it with fresh electors, accountable to you, the voter, and not themselves.
Popular Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall now prefers abolishing it. That says something right there. I no longer see him suffering from insenaty. His mind is clear. Perhaps it is I and others who suffer after continually bashing our heads against the wall, expecting the same result.
As Manning said in his letter, even after decades of the infinite hours spent by countless people on the issue of senate reform, essentially the patience runs out, and it is time the Prime Minister, fed up with the complacency, proposes to free us from the chains and ends the thing.
At least then, finally, we can stop the insenaty.
1 comment:
I used to be in the EEE camp. Now I'm in the abolish camp. The last thing we need is more politicians, more government, and legislative gridlock like that screwy system in the USA.
Getting abolishment approved by the HofC, the Senate and 7 Provinces with 50% of the population probably won't happen.
EEE won't happen either, for the same reason.
Post a Comment